Transphobic ads win the day in Alaska

The “culture wars” in the United States, today, are fought on social media.

Sociological Images shared this example of a campaign that ran against a proposed ballot proposition (“Prop 5”) in Anchorage, Alaska, that would have extended citywide anti-discrimination protections to sexual orientation and transgender identity:

SI’s Amy L. Stone writes,

“In addition to the use of stereotypically-presented “transvestites” to represent all transgender individuals as grotesque and laughable, the ads also argue that employers should have the right to discriminate if they think their customers are prejudiced toward a particular group or uncomfortable with them in certain jobs — an argument that has been used to resist allowing racial minorities and women into various careers. The ads also suggest that Anchorage is already sufficiently tolerant and thus doesn’t need to address the issues Proposition 5 supporters claimed were a problem.”

Ads that raise fears about transvestites teaching in the classroom have been used since the 1970s during ballot measure campaigns, and the Religious Right has been raising concerns about transgender women in women’s bathrooms since the late 1980s. These two ads from the Anchorage Proposition 5 campaign are among the newest additions to the long tradition of ads that rely on stereotypes of LGBT individuals as predatory, dangerous to have around children, and having ulterior motives.

Fear. While it has proven mostly useless in getting people to change their behaviour through marketing, it can be extremely effective if it reinforces pre-existing anxieties about “others” — even if they are comically exaggerated.

“People who operate their business in Anchorage would have to violate their conscience or be threatened with lawsuits and eventually 30 days in jail if they refuse to violate their conscience,” said Jim Minnery, a spokesperson for the group Protect Anchorage – Vote No On Prop 5.

Reframing the recognition of one person’s human rights as the violation of another’s religious freedoms is a common theme in the United States.

In this case, the approach worked. Prop 5 was defeated in April.

A third ad in the series (not featured in the SI post) is even more insidious. It presents the case that both gay and straight employers should have the “right” to discriminate based on sexual orientation:

  1. 1

    De VS is nu eenmaal een heel achterlijk land, dat komt vermoedelijk door z’n geografische isolement (maar vijf procent van de Amerikanen heeft een paspoort), de overgrote meerderheid komt de (deel-)staatsgrens nooit over.

    Verder kennen Amerikanen geen talen, en wordt hen gehersenspoeld dat de VS het beste land van de wereld is, zodat kennis nemen van andere culturen er ook al niet van komt.
    Dan is er de ellende dat de Founding Fathers nog steeds worden gevolgd, tenminste, dat wordt beweerd, en dat die zich deels op de bijbel beriepen.
    De kreet Manifest Destiny, het idee dat de VS de wereld moet beheersen, completeert de ramp.

    Er is helaas weinig kritiek op de VS, en op VS presidenten.
    De bejubelde Roosevelt, de man van de tweede wereldoorlog, wordt alleen in een boek van Barbara Tuchman over ‘vinegar Joe’, Stilwell, Roosevelt’s vertrouweling in China bij Chiang Kai Tsek, als idioot neergezet.
    De Poolse ambassadeur in de VS tijdens de tweede wereldoorlog in Washington kwam te laat tot de conclusie dat Roosevelt vooral een goed acteur was, en zo verdween Polen tot 1985 ongeveer opnieuw als zelfstandig land.